The Guardian’s Anti-Semitic Explanation For Shalit Deal

Over the years, we’ve covered some vicious and despicable pieces in the media, many of them published in The Guardian. But amongst the many commentaries and analyses of the Gilad Shalit prisoner deal, one by Deborah Orr in The Guardian’s print edition really plumbs the depths.

Orr writes:

All this, I fear, is simply an indication of how inured the world has become to the obscene idea that Israeli lives are more important than Palestinian lives. Netanyahu argues that he acted because he values Shalit’s life so greatly.

Yet who is surprised really, to learn that Netanyahu sees one Israeli’s freedom as a fair exchange for the freedom of so many Palestinians? Likewise, Hamas wished to use their human bargaining chip to gain release for as many Palestinians as they could. They don’t have much to bargain with.

Is Orr really suggesting that Israel’s desire to get back one of its soldiers at such a high price is driven by some racist sense of valuing Israeli or Jewish life above all others? Apparently so:

At the same time, however, there is something abject in their eagerness to accept a transfer that tacitly acknowledges what so many Zionists believe – that the lives of the chosen are of hugely greater consequence than those of their unfortunate neighbours.

The abuse of the concept of the “chosen people” refers specifically to Jews and is commonly employed by anti-Semites to falsely assert that Jews claim to be superior to non-Jews not only in a theological sense but also in a racial one.

As Joseph Telushkin asks:

Does Judaism believe that chosenness endows Jews with special rights in the way racist ideologies endow those born into the “right race”? Not at all. The most famous verse in the Bible on the subject of chosenness says the precise opposite: “You alone have I singled out of all the families of the earth. That is why I call you to account for all your iniquities” (Amos 3:2). Chosenness is so unconnected to any notion of race that Jews believe that the Messiah himself will descend from Ruth, a non-­Jewish woman who converted to Judaism.

The fact that Israel values the life of a solitary individual so much that it is prepared to release hundreds of Palestinians responsible for some of the most appalling terrorist outrages instead tells us how much Israel values human life. This overwhelming desire to return one of its own people is a value to be proud of.

Deborah Orr

Orr appears to be distressed at the implication of a deal that sees one Jew as the equivalent of 1000 Arabs. If this is the case, then Orr would be better directing her ire at Hamas for demanding and setting such an unbalanced equivalance.

That Deborah Orr is prepared to descend to the depths of anti-Semitism to claim that Israel is motivated by racism says much about her own warped values. That The Guardian was prepared to publish such an obscene commentary merely confirms the publication’s vicious anti-Israel bent.

Send your considered comments to The Guardian –letters@guardian.co.uk

 

About IsraeliIDF - Israeli Internet Defense Force

צבא ההגנה לישראל באינטרנט ✡ Report Antisemitism @ ReportAntisemitism@IsraeliIDF.org ✡ Subscribe 2 IsraeliIDF 2 ensure U never miss a single Hot-Button ISSUE! ✡ Join us on Facebook @ http://www.facebook.com/groups/IsraeliIDF ✡ ✡ Like IsraeliIDF on Facebook @ http://www.facebook.com/IsraeliIDF ✡ Join the IsraeliIDF Twitter Team @ http://twitter.com/IsraeliIDF ✡ We report on the ground in Israel & across the Diaspora ✡ ✡ RU Passionate about Israel & able 2 type? Then Join our team of contributors! ✡ To Join IsraeliIDF email JoinUS@IsraeliIDF.org ✡ We LIVE to expose ALL vetted Inconvenient Truths the Western Media IGNORES ✡ ✡ WE R PRO-PEACE ✡ Our Aim ... 2 RE-WORK R World 2Gether & RE-Create it w/out H8 & ANTISEMITISM ✡ ✡ If 4 NO other reason, join us 2 Stand BY Israel & join the rest of the world in proclaiming Israel's right to live in PEACE! ✡ ✡ We were NOT put on this earth to OBSERVE the status quo, but to effect change & make things better, dare we say "Imagine" it 2 perfection! ✡ ✡ We defend Israel's right to exist, to defend themselves, to not let themselves be exterminated a second time in modern history ✡ ✡ The truth about Hamas & Islamic Jihad is that they don't prevent Israel from existing or even flourishing, they prevent Palestine from coming into existence ✡

Leave IsraeliIDF a FeedBack!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s